UNSECURED LOAD ACCIDENTS
How Falling Cargo Creates Liability Across the Supply Chain
Key Takeaways
- The NHTSA estimates that road debris causes approximately 50,000 crashes annually in the United States, and a significant portion comes from unsecured or improperly secured cargo.
- Both 49 CFR Part 393 Subpart I and KRS 189.150 impose cargo securement requirements, and drivers are legally required to inspect securement before each trip and again after the first 50 miles and every 3 hours or 150 miles thereafter.
- Responsibility for unsecured cargo can reach the truck driver, trucking company, loading crew, and cargo owner or shipper.
The Deadly Physics of Unsecured Cargo
When a heavy piece of cargo falls from a truck traveling at highway speed, it can hit the road with tremendous force, and other vehicles often cannot stop in time. The initial falling object may not even make direct contact, but the secondary crash it causes can be just as catastrophic, and liability can reach the driver, carrier, loading crew, and shipper.
Every year, the NHTSA estimates that road debris causes approximately 50,000 crashes annually in the United States, killing hundreds of people. A significant portion of that debris comes from unsecured or improperly secured cargo falling from commercial trucks. Under 49 CFR Part 393 Subpart I and KRS 189.150, both federal and Kentucky law impose clear cargo securement requirements on trucking companies. When they fail those requirements, our dedicated trucking team holds them accountable.
What Federal and Kentucky Law Require
Dual Regulatory Framework for Cargo Securement
Both federal and state law apply to unsecured cargo cases in Kentucky:
- 49 CFR Part 393 Subpart I (FMCSA), specifies the type and number of tie-downs required based on cargo weight, shape, and dimensions. Mandates proper blocking, bracing, and anchor points.
- KRS 189.150, Kentucky state law requiring that all loads be safely secured to prevent shifting, leaking, or falling onto public highways.
- Drivers are legally required to inspect cargo securement before each trip and again after the first 50 miles and every 3 hours or 150 miles thereafter during transit.
“They actually care. They go above and beyond for their clients and protect you like family.”
– Savannah F.
Who Can Be Held Liable?
-
The truck driver
Required by law to inspect and verify cargo securement before and during every trip. Driving with a visibly unsecured load or failing to check restraints is direct negligence.
-
The trucking company
Responsible for training, equipment maintenance, and overall loading procedures. If the company’s culture pressures drivers to skip securement checks to save time, the carrier bears liability.
-
The loading crew
Third-party loaders at distribution centers who physically secure cargo can be held directly accountable when their improper technique causes the failure.
-
The cargo owner or shipper
Shippers who insist on unsafe loading configurations or refuse to provide proper dunnage and restraint equipment share in the resulting liability.
Required by law to inspect and verify cargo securement before and during every trip. Driving with a visibly unsecured load or failing to check restraints is direct negligence.
Responsible for training, equipment maintenance, and overall loading procedures. If the company’s culture pressures drivers to skip securement checks to save time, the carrier bears liability.
Third-party loaders at distribution centers who physically secure cargo can be held directly accountable when their improper technique causes the failure.
Shippers who insist on unsafe loading configurations or refuse to provide proper dunnage and restraint equipment share in the resulting liability.
One common myth: You can only make a claim if the cargo directly hit your vehicle. That’s wrong. If you swerved to avoid debris and crashed, the trucking operation that created the road hazard is still liable under Kentucky law, even without direct contact.
Evidence We Secure in Unsecured Load Cases
- Loading manifests and bills of lading, document what was loaded, how it was secured, and who was responsible
- Cargo inspection records and pre-trip inspection reports (DVIRs)
- Photographs and video from traffic cameras, dashcams, and nearby businesses
- Physical evidence from the roadway, tie-down fragments, anchor point wear, cargo remnants
- Accident reconstruction analysis showing how the cargo failed and what it struck
- Carrier’s training records and internal loading procedures
Related truck crash topics: See our Kentucky truck accident lawyer page, tire blowout truck crash page, and jackknife truck crash page.
Frequently Asked Questions.
Can I recover if the truck’s cargo caused me to swerve but didn’t hit me directly?
Yes. Under Kentucky law, if a trucking operation created a dangerous condition on the highway, including debris or cargo that caused an emergency maneuver, and that condition caused your crash, the responsible parties can be held liable even without direct contact.
How do you prove what caused the cargo to fall?
Through physical evidence from the crash scene, expert analysis of the cargo’s failure points, review of the loading manifest and bill of lading, inspection records (DVIRs), and comparison of what was required versus what was actually used under 49 CFR Part 393.
Who is liable when a third-party loading company loaded the cargo?
Both the loading company and the trucking carrier can share liability. The carrier is required by federal law to ensure cargo is properly secured before the truck moves, regardless of who loaded it, and the loading company may be independently liable for negligence in its own loading practices.
What are the most common causes of unsecured load accidents?
Improper tie-downs, poor loading technique that fails to center heavy items over axles, overloaded trucks that exceed the Gross Vehicle Weight Rating, missing secondary restraints for cargo like metal coils or pipes, and failure to re-check securement during transit are the most common causes.
What evidence is secured in an unsecured load case?
Loading manifests and bills of lading, cargo inspection and pre-trip inspection reports, photographs and video from traffic cameras and dashcams, physical evidence from the roadway such as tie-down fragments, and accident reconstruction analysis are all part of building the case.
Get More. Get It Faster.
Get It With Sam Aguiar.
- ✓Bigger Share Guarantee On Every Case
- ✓$0 Out-Of-Pocket Forever
- ✓No Fee Increase If Your Case Goes To Litigation
- ✓Dedicated Three-Person Case Team
- ✓Forbes Best-In-State Recognition
- ✓1,000+ Five-Star Google Reviews